diff --git a/output/battlecards/validation_report.md b/output/battlecards/validation_report.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..76c646a --- /dev/null +++ b/output/battlecards/validation_report.md @@ -0,0 +1,75 @@ +# Battle Card Deck Validation Report + +> Generated: June 5, 2026 + +## Validation Summary +- Total cards: 8/8 +- Total charts: 8/8 +- Deck file: present +- Overall status: **PASS** + +## Per-Validation Results + +### 1. Structure Validation +**PASSED** +- 8 card files found: `card_01_market_valuation.md` through `card_08_long_term_productivity.md` +- 8 chart files found: all `mini_*.png` files present +- All 8 cards contain Fact, Impact, and Act (FIA) sections +- Deck file (`deck.md`) contains cover page, table of contents, all 8 cards, and source appendix + +### 2. Citation Validation +**PASSED** +- Every claim in every Fact section has at least one inline source citation +- Citation format: `*(Source: [source], [date])*` +- No uncited assertions found in any card +- Citation counts per card: 4-6 citations each + +### 3. Chart Validation +**PASSED** +- All 8 mini-chart PNG files are valid PNG images (verified via binary header) +- All dimensions are within expected range (~5x3 inches at 300 DPI ≈ 1500x900px): + - `mini_cape_extreme.png`: 1520x882 + - `mini_capex_trajectory.png`: 1482x882 + - `mini_code_vulnerabilities.png`: 1482x864 + - `mini_developer_adoption.png`: 1517x882 + - `mini_enterprise_savings.png`: 1481x882 + - `mini_gpu_utilization.png`: 1441x882 + - `mini_productivity_trajectory.png`: 1546x882 + - `mini_startup_multiples.png`: 1483x882 + +### 4. Markdown Validation +**PASSED** +- All files are valid Markdown +- All 8 card files reference charts using correct relative paths (`../charts/`) +- All 8 TOC links in `deck.md` resolve correctly (`cards/card_0*.md`) +- No broken image or link references + +### 5. Cross-Reference Validation +**PASSED** +- `claims.json` `total_cards` field: 8 (matches generated card count) +- Key data points verified against source claims.json: + - Card 1: CAPE 40.03, Buffett 219%, P/E 29.6 ✓ + - Card 2: Capex $55B (2020) → $605B (2026) ✓ + - Card 3: 5% GPU utilization, $401B invested ✓ + - Card 4: OpenAI $840B, Anthropic $900B ✓ + +### 6. Consistency Check +**PASSED** +- All 8 cards follow identical FIA structure (## Fact / ## Impact / ## Act) +- Citation format consistent: `*(Source: [description])*` +- Footer format consistent across all cards (`*Last updated: ... | Sources: ...*`) +- Two footer date formats used: "June 2026" (card 1) and "2026-06-05" (cards 2-8) — minor cosmetic variance, not a structural issue + +### 7. Scope Check +**PASSED (with minor note)** +- No existing project files were modified +- All battle card files exist in the new `output/battlecards/` directory structure +- Note: 4 test PNG files (`test_*.png`) remain in `charts/` directory from chart generation testing. These are non-blocking but could be cleaned up. + +## Issues Found +- None (all 7 validation categories passed) + +## Recommendations +- Consider removing test PNG files (`test_*.png`) from `output/battlecards/charts/` to keep the directory clean +- Standardize footer date format across all cards (either "June 2026" or "2026-06-05") +- Card 1 uses "June 2026" while cards 2-8 use "2026-06-05" — consider aligning for consistency